Bold = top recommendations
All of Us Villains | All of Us Villains #1 | Amanda Foody and Christine Lynn Herman
The Bone Houses | Emily Lloyd-Jones
The Change | Kirsten Miller
A Dark and Starless Forest | Sarah Hollowell
Hotel Magnifique | Emily J. Taylor
The House in the Cerulean Sea | TJ Klune
House of Hollow | Krystal Sutherland
The Ladies of the Secret Circus | Constance Sayers
A Lesson in Vengeance | Victoria Lee
The Midnight Library | Matt Haig
Ninth House | Alex Stern #1 | Leigh Bardugo
Ordinary Monsters | The Talents Trilogy #1 | J. M. Miro
Piranesi | Susanna Clarke
Siren Queen | Nghi Vo
Sorrowland | Rivers Solomon
The Ten Thousand Doors of January | Alix E. Harrow
Under the Whispering Door | TJ Klune