Aesthetic image for The Broken Girls by Simone St. James.

The Broken Girls by Simone St. James

In Reviews by AsterLeave a Comment

Published in 2018, The Broken Girls by Simone St. James tells the story of Fiona in 2014 and the broken girls of Idlewild Hall in 1950. Idlewild Hall is a girls boarding school filled with the rebellious, the thinkers, and the illegitimate - girls that don't have a proper place in society. Four roommates are bonded together in 1950 by the terror of what lurks within the boundaries of Idlewild Hall.

64 years later the decrepit Hall is being restored by an unnamed benefactor and Fiona jumps on the opportunity. Its purchase provides Fiona the ability to delve into the history of the place and all that has happened on its land including the discovery of her sister's body. The murderer has been convicted and yet, Fiona believes there are missing pieces of the puzzle.

Less than a week later, a body is discovered on the grounds and Fiona is swept away by the discovery of another female body, this time from the past. One discovery that links the past to the present bringing secrets forward that many prayed were never told. 

| Why The Broken Girls Is Worth Your Time

This thriller is filled with pain. Pain that refuses to let go even after you've finished the novel. If you are searching for an all-consuming read that leaves you contemplating the outcome, The Broken Girls is worth your time. Set in two era's, 2014 and 1950, The Broken Girls tells the tale of broken girls and how one place can tie them together decades later.

If you are yet to read Simone St. James's works and are looking to start with one of her highest rated works, then check out this novel. It is a delectable read you will enjoy because of its fluidity, intrigue, and paranormal incorporation.

| Plot Progression

The plot of The Broken Girls is written with structure. It goes from viewpoint A to B to A to B and so forth without breaking flow allowing for a creation of a fluid story.

This is a slow-paced and enjoyable plot that will make you as a reader slow down and appreciate the in's and out's of characters and how mysteries from the past can still be unravelled in the present.

Good plot. Thumbs up!

| Characters

I go more into depth in My Thoughts but the characters in The Broken Girls are my favourite. They are absolutely broken people whose pain is so understandable and realistic that you are immediately drawn to them.

Cece, Katie, Sonia, Roberta, and Fiona are all broken and their pain, ever so unique and warranted, seeps into your bones and makes you think "oh damn, that is awful." You feel for these characters and is why you should read this novel. These are characters to get lost into and root for - characters that make it worth your time.

| Ending

The ending closes the chapter on Idlewild Hall. Unlike other thriller works, there is no sudden twist or BANG within the last few pages but instead a comfortable finish.

It is an ending that will make you happy you devoted your time to the novel. It is not an insanity riddled ending but not a forgettable one either. A solid ending to a solid book.

Main Genre | Thriller

Year Published | 2018

Rating | 8.5 / 10

Worth Your Time? Yes.

| My Thoughts

WARNING: Skip My Thoughts for a spoiler free review.

I enjoy Simone St. James's way of writing. I find her fluidity and ease of intertwining the past with the present highly enjoyable, so enjoyable that it leaves me craving more of her works.

I decided to read The Broken Girls because after finishing The Sun Down Motel, I knew I wanted more. Plus, I have an affinity for boarding school stories and The Broken Girls ticked two boxes for me. And guess what, The Broken Girls was exactly what I craved and I loved reading it. C'mon, a ghost mystery surreptitiously tied into the present? What a delightful snack this novel was to read.

The part I appreciated most about this novel was surprisingly not Idlewild Hall but the relationships Fiona had with others. They felt genuine and more powerful compared to other relationships you tend to read in thrillers. Fiona and her dad, Malcolm bonded further together because of grief and so did Jamie and Fiona. All of the main characters were searching for solace, looking for peace in a corrupt, evil, and haunted world. That is what I liked most about The Broken Girls, that the cracks were glue-able, always a part of the character but no longer stopping them from being whole.

The ending was insanity. Did anybody else suspect Garrett? I thought he was an arrogant man but not a manipulative sleaze bag and don't you just feel for Jamie? The Father he has looked up to for so longer, a corrupt and evil main. Painful.

Dang, these characters were broken and because of their pain, the ending was cathartic. Simone St. James does it again with The Broken Girls and I am stoked to read her other works.

| Your Thoughts

Did you decide that The Broken Girls is worth a read? If so, let me know what you thought of the novel below! And check out My Thoughts once finished for guess what, my thoughts on this literary adventure!

Are you looking for something else? Check out these thriller novels instead!

Are you looking for other works by Simone St. James? Check out The Sun Down Motel, maybe it will be your next read! (PS. It should be)

Was this worth an hour of your time? Because it was worth an hour of mine.

The pinterest image for The Broken Girls by Simone St. James book review. There is a blue floral print background with the novel centered in the middle and the cover facing the front.
Buy On Amazon

Disclaimer (yippie!): Aster's Book Hour is an Amazon Associate. It earns a small commission from qualifying purchases attached to the Amazon affiliate link above.

Leave a Comment