Bold = top recommendations
All of Us Villains | All of Us Villains #1 | Amanda Foody and Christine Lynn Herman
As Good as Dead | A Good Girl's Guide to Murder #3 | Holly Jackson
The Box in the Woods | Truly Devious #4 | Maureen Johnson
A Cloud of Outrageous Blue | Vesper Stamper
The Companion | Katie Alender
The Cousins | Karen M. McManus
Dark and Shallow Lies | Ginny Myers Sain
A Dark and Starless Forest | Sarah Hollowell
The Dead and the Dark | Courtney Gould
The Dead of Night | Tomorrow Series #2 | John Marsden
The Degenerates | J. Albert Mann
Good Girl, Bad Blood | A Good Girl's Guide to Murder #2 | Holly Jackson
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder | A Good Girl's Guide to Murder #1 | Holly Jackson
Five Total Strangers | Natalie D. Richards
Hotel Magnifique | Emily J. Taylor
House of Horror | Krystal Sutherland
The Inheritance Games | The Inheritance Games #1 | Jennifer Lynn Barnes
The Ivies | Alexa Donne
A Killing Frost | Tomorrow Series #3 | John Marsden
A Lesson in Vengeance | Victoria Lee
The Loop | Loop #1 | Ben Oliver
The Luck of the Titanic | Stacey Lee
The Project | Courtney Summers
One of Us Is Lying | One of Us Is Lying #1 | Karen M. McManus
One of Us Is Next | One of Us Is Lying #2 | Karen M. McManus
The Outsiders | SE Hilton
Switch | AS King
That Weekend | Kara Thomas
These Deadly Games | Diana Urban
Tomorrow, When the War Began | Tomorrow Series #1 | John Marsden
White Smoke | Tiffany D. Jackson
You'll Be the Death of Me | Karen M. McManus